Discover the delightful taste of Sandwich Bread. Handcrafted with love and baked to golden perfection, this fluffy loaf is the perfect canvas for your favorite sandwiches or toast toppings. Experience the warm, homestyle goodness in every slice, and bring a touch of homemade charm to your table.

My Story

Welcome to Creative Cottage Treasures, where every bite tells a story of local artisanship and heartfelt creativity! I'm Ally Carter, the proud owner and passionate food lover behind this venture. Here, we believe in the power of quality ingredients and the magic of locally created food. Each of our delectable treats is crafted with love, ensuring that every piece embodies the rich heritage and flavors of our community. Supporting local farmers and producers isn't just a business choice; it's a commitment to sustaining the vibrant tapestry of our local economy. Join us in celebrating the joy of homemade goodness that nourishes the soul and connects us all. Thank you for being part of our delicious journey!

Sandwhich Bread

Our sourdough bagels are a delightful twist on a classic favorite, made with a slow-fermented sourdough starter for a rich, tangy flavor and perfectly chewy texture. Each bagel is hand-shaped, boiled, and baked to golden perfection, ensuring an authentic artisan experience. Enjoy them plain, topped with seeds, or loaded with your favorite spreads—they're perfect for breakfast, lunch, or anytime cravings!

Bagels

Indulge in the delightful taste of our Strawberry Mini Cake. Each cake is a perfect blend of fluffy strawberry sponge and luscious buttercream, making it an irresistible treat for any occasion.

Strawberry Mini Cake 

 Bagels Half Dozen 

Bagels  Dozen 

Indulge in the best of both worlds with our brookies! These irresistible treats combine a brownie's rich, fudgy goodness with the soft, chewy delight of a chocolate chip cookie. Perfectly baked for a crisp edge and gooey center, they’re a sweet harmony of flavors and textures in every bite. A must-try for any chocolate lover!

 Brookies (4)

  Brookies (6)

Experience the perfect blend of tangy flavor and a soft, airy bite with Sourdough Sandwich Bread. Each loaf embodies our commitment to quality, using only the finest natural ingredients for that deliciously wholesome taste you crave. Elevate your sandwiches and toast with this artisanal bread that turns every meal into a treasured treat.

Sourdough Sandwhich Bread

Indulge in the delightful fusion of flavors with our Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake Sourdough from Creative Cottage Treasures. This artisanal bread perfectly marries the tangy zest of lemon, the sweetness of blueberries, and the creamy richness of cheesecake, creating an unforgettable taste experience. Please note, this product contains wheat and is compatible with wheat-inclusive diets.

Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake Sourdough

Discover the bold flavors of our Jalapeño Cheddar artisanal bread, handcrafted by Creative Cottage Treasures. This savory loaf combines sharp cheddar cheese with spicy jalapenos, creating a perfect blend of heat and cheesy goodness—ideal for sandwiches or on its own. Please note, this product contains wheat and milk.

Jalapeno Cheddar

Indulge in the rustic charm of Creative Cottage Treasures' Plain Sourdough, a handcrafted bread baked to perfection in Columbus, Indiana. This artisanal loaf, made with the finest ingredients, offers a delightful tang and a chewy texture that pairs beautifully with any meal.

Plain Sourdough

Indulge in the rich, savory delight of Creative Cottage Treasures’ Garlic Parmesan Sourdough, an artisanal masterpiece baked to perfection in Columbus, IN. This golden-crusted bread is infused with robust garlic and nutty Parmesan, making every slice a divine experience. Please note, this product contains wheat and is suitable for those with wheat-compatible diets.

Garlic Parmesan Sourdough

Brookies Singles

Indulge in the zesty delight of Lemon Blueberry Scones. These scones marry the tang of fresh lemons with the sweetness of ripe blueberries, offering a perfect balance of flavors in every bite. Ideal for breakfast or an afternoon treat, each scone promises a homemade touch that brings a piece of cottage comfort to your table.

Lemon Blueberry Scones

3 Lemon Blueberry Scones

Mother’s Day Brunch Box – Preorder Now! Make her morning sweet, cozy, and delicious with a box full of handcrafted treats! Each box includes: 1 Mini Sourdough Loaf – choose Butter Croissant or Chocolate Chip Butter Croissant 2 Jumbo Coffee Cake Muffins with cinnamon streusel topping 3 Chocolate Chip Scones – tender, buttery, and chocolatey Pre-order by Wednesday, May 7thDelivery available Friday, May 9th and Saturday, May 10thPerfectly packaged and ready to gift! Limited boxes are available!

Mother's Day Brunch Box`

Indulge in the delightful taste of our freshly baked Rolls (12). These soft, golden rolls are perfect for any meal, offering a homemade touch to your family dinners or special occasions. Savor the comforting aroma and fluffy texture.

Rolls Dozen

Liz Thompson is a talented local home food artisan based in Beech Grove, Indiana. She runs a custom cake shop that offers a variety of cakes and cupcakes for purchase to take away or for custom orders. With cakes available for all occasions, Liz takes pride in creating delicious and visually stunning creations that are sure to impress.

Recently, Liz posted about some of her latest creations on social media. She showcased the ever-popular Wednesday cake, adorned with delicious buttercream frosting. She also displayed an adorable little bee cake that she made for a baby shower, complete with the hashtags #beecakes, #babyshowercakes, and #indysbestcake. Liz was delighted to have the opportunity to create a nostalgic Barbie cake, expressing her excitement for the project. Lastly, Liz shared her joy in making fun and creative ice cream cakes for twins celebrating their first birthday, highlighting her love for when customers give her the freedom to be creative. Her work also extends to elegant wedding cakes, as demonstrated through her simple and elegant design shared with the hashtags #weddingcakes, #indianaroofballroom, and #indysbestcake.

Welcome to Creative Cottage Treasures, where every bite tells a story of local artisanship and heartfelt creativity! I'm Ally Carter, the proud owner and passionate food lover behind this venture. Here, we believe in the power of quality ingredients and the magic of locally created food. Each of our delectable treats is crafted with love, ensuring that every piece embodies the rich heritage and flavors of our community. Supporting local farmers and producers isn't just a business choice; it's a commitment to sustaining the vibrant tapestry of our local economy. Join us in celebrating the joy of homemade goodness that nourishes the soul and connects us all. Thank you for being part of our delicious journey!

Creative Cottage Treasures  | , IN

Please provide your details and message below and I'll be in touch soon.

Get in Touch

Shop our back to school treats and make the start of the school year extra special!

📚 Start the School Year Right

Freshly baked and full of flavor—perfect for your holiday feast or as a thoughtful gift!

From the best specialty food artisans to your home in no time!

Results near Beech Grove, IN

$5.00

$2.50

$5.00

$15.00

$30.00

$12.00

$18.00

$5.00

$14.00

$14.00

$10.00

$14.00

$3.00

$4.00

$12.00

$20.00

$10.00

Become a Seller

For Sellers

Seller Log In

Become a Seller

Who is Castiron?

Why Sell on Castiron Marketplace?

Pricing

Resources

About Castiron

Contact Support

Return Policy

Sitemap

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Sitemap