Our sourdough bagels are a delightful twist on a classic favorite, made with a slow-fermented sourdough starter for a rich, tangy flavor and perfectly chewy texture. Each bagel is hand-shaped, boiled, and baked to golden perfection, ensuring an authentic artisan experience. Enjoy them plain, topped with seeds, or loaded with your favorite spreads—they're perfect for breakfast, lunch, or anytime cravings!

My Story

Welcome to Creative Cottage Treasures, where every bite tells a story of local artisanship and heartfelt creativity! I'm Ally Carter, the proud owner and passionate food lover behind this venture. Here, we believe in the power of quality ingredients and the magic of locally created food. Each of our delectable treats is crafted with love, ensuring that every piece embodies the rich heritage and flavors of our community. Supporting local farmers and producers isn't just a business choice; it's a commitment to sustaining the vibrant tapestry of our local economy. Join us in celebrating the joy of homemade goodness that nourishes the soul and connects us all. Thank you for being part of our delicious journey!

 Bagels Half Dozen 

Indulge in the zesty delight of Lemon Blueberry Scones. These scones marry the tang of fresh lemons with the sweetness of ripe blueberries, offering a perfect balance of flavors in every bite. Ideal for breakfast or an afternoon treat, each scone promises a homemade touch that brings a piece of cottage comfort to your table.

3 Lemon Blueberry Scones

Indulge in the delightful taste of our freshly baked Rolls (12). These soft, golden rolls are perfect for any meal, offering a homemade touch to your family dinners or special occasions. Savor the comforting aroma and fluffy texture.

Rolls Dozen

Discover the delightful taste of Sandwich Bread. Handcrafted with love and baked to golden perfection, this fluffy loaf is the perfect canvas for your favorite sandwiches or toast toppings. Experience the warm, homestyle goodness in every slice, and bring a touch of homemade charm to your table.

Sandwhich Bread

Pride Pancake Mix 🌈🥞 Celebrate love, color, and community—one fluffy pancake at a time! Our Pride Pancake Mix is a festive blend that makes 10–12 soft, golden pancakes bursting with rainbow sprinkles in every bite. Just add your wet ingredients, cook, and serve up joy. Whether you're celebrating Pride Month or just love a colorful start to your day, these pancakes are a sweet way to show your pride and support. Because breakfast should be as bold and beautiful as you are.

Pride Pancake Mix

Bagels  Dozen 

Indulge in the rustic charm of Creative Cottage Treasures' Plain Sourdough, a handcrafted bread baked to perfection in Columbus, Indiana. This artisanal loaf, made with the finest ingredients, offers a delightful tang and a chewy texture that pairs beautifully with any meal.

Plain Sourdough

Indulge in the best of both worlds with our brookies! These irresistible treats combine a brownie's rich, fudgy goodness with the soft, chewy delight of a chocolate chip cookie. Perfectly baked for a crisp edge and gooey center, they’re a sweet harmony of flavors and textures in every bite. A must-try for any chocolate lover!

Brookies Singles

Lemon Blueberry Scones

Indulge in the rich, savory delight of Creative Cottage Treasures’ Garlic Parmesan Sourdough, an artisanal masterpiece baked to perfection in Columbus, IN. This golden-crusted bread is infused with robust garlic and nutty Parmesan, making every slice a divine experience. Please note, this product contains wheat and is suitable for those with wheat-compatible diets.

Garlic Parmesan Sourdough

Indulge in the delightful fusion of flavors with our Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake Sourdough from Creative Cottage Treasures. This artisanal bread perfectly marries the tangy zest of lemon, the sweetness of blueberries, and the creamy richness of cheesecake, creating an unforgettable taste experience. Please note, this product contains wheat and is compatible with wheat-inclusive diets.

Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake Sourdough

 Brookies (4)

Bagels

  Brookies (6)

S’mores Sourdough Campfire nostalgia meets artisan baking in this irresistible twist on a classic. Our S’mores Sourdough combines the tangy goodness of naturally fermented sourdough with pockets of gooey marshmallows, rich chocolate chunks, and graham cracker crumbles baked right in. Every slice brings the magic of a summer night—no campfire required. It's perfect, sweet, chewy, and unforgettable.

S'mores Sourdough

Experience the perfect blend of tangy flavor and a soft, airy bite with Sourdough Sandwich Bread. Each loaf embodies our commitment to quality, using only the finest natural ingredients for that deliciously wholesome taste you crave. Elevate your sandwiches and toast with this artisanal bread that turns every meal into a treasured treat.

Sourdough Sandwhich Bread

Discover the bold flavors of our Jalapeño Cheddar artisanal bread, handcrafted by Creative Cottage Treasures. This savory loaf combines sharp cheddar cheese with spicy jalapenos, creating a perfect blend of heat and cheesy goodness—ideal for sandwiches or on its own. Please note, this product contains wheat and milk.

Jalapeno Cheddar

Fernanda Masullo - Cookies, is a local home food artisan specializing in decorated cookies. With a passion for baking and a talent for creating beautifully designed treats, Fernanda offers online courses and shares helpful tips on her YouTube channel. She is known for her attention to detail and creativity, making her cookies perfect for any occasion. From her recent posts, it is clear that Fernanda is excited about the Halloween season and has a stunning collection of spooky-themed cookies available for order. With limited stock, customers are encouraged to place their orders by October 13th to ensure they don't miss out on these delectable treats. Whether it's a cute ghost, a jack-o-lantern, or a little Halloween spoiler, Fernanda's cookies are sure to impress both visually and in taste. Order soon and stay tuned for more delicious creations from Fernanda Masullo - Cookies.

Katy-Did is a local home food artisan based in Columbus, Indiana, specializing in custom decorated sugar cookies. With a passion for creating delicious and visually stunning treats, Katy-Did offers a wide array of designs and flavors to satisfy any sweet tooth. Whether it's for a birthday celebration, seasonal treat, or supporting a local fundraiser, Katy-Did's cookies are the perfect addition to any occasion. Stay tuned to see the outcome of Katy-Did's latest project, as her kitchen gets messy with love and dedication to creating something truly special.

Katy-Did recently shared some exciting updates on social media, including a birthday celebration for Mason, the anticipation for the fall season, and her support for a local organization called REACH. Having personally experienced the benefits of REACH's summer program for her son, Katy-Did is a strong advocate for this wonderful initiative. She proudly participated in REACH's second annual fundraiser by including her treat boxes in their goody bags, showing her commitment to supporting the community. With Katy-Did's dedication and passion evident in every project she takes on, it's clear that her latest creation, inspired by Rescue Bots, will be a hit for Aiden!

Jessica is a local home food artisan in Columbus, IN, specializing in custom cookies and teaching cookie decorating classes. With her business, Artistry Cookie Co, she offers a range of delicious and beautifully decorated cookies. Jessica's classes are a hit among cookie enthusiasts, as she provides everything needed for the class, except for the most important ingredient - the participants themselves. In her Halloween Cookie Class, attendees can expect to learn various decorating techniques, receive pre-made cookies, ready-to-go icings, and all the tools necessary to create spooky masterpieces. Jessica's classes are not only educational but also fun and engaging, ensuring a delightful experience for all participants.

Have you ever wanted to learn how to decorate cookies like a pro? Look no further than Jessica's Artistry Cookie Co in Columbus, IN. Jessica, a skilled cookie artist and teacher, offers an incredible 2-hour cookie decorating class that is packed with value. In the class, participants will receive 6 cookies ready to decorate, 4 pre-prepared icings, all the necessary tools, and even secrets and tricks of the trade. Jessica will guide attendees through each step of the process, ensuring that no experience is needed to create beautiful and tasty cookies. Plus, participants will go home with their creations in a handy bakers box and to-go bags. With a passion for sharing her expertise, Jessica's classes are a must-attend for anyone looking to enhance their cookie decorating skills and have an enjoyable time in the process.

5 Daughters (Brittany Ortman) is a talented local home food artisan and stay-at-home momma of 6 little ones. She runs a small in-home bakery that offers a wide variety of delicious treats, including cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and more. Brittany's creations are known for their simple yet elegant style, using vibrant colors and delightful flavors.

Recently, she posted a simple and fun style birthday cake for one of their favorite people, hoping that they had an amazing day. She also showcased a chocolate and Bourbon cake with little gold accents for a surprise party, expressing her personal fondness for the gold accents. Furthermore, she displayed vibrant blue-themed cookies for a Volleyball Senior Night, highlighting the contrasting colors against the bright white. Additionally, she shared a picture of a Red Velvet cupcake with cream cheese buttercream, illustrating how simple designs can be so elegant. Finally, Brittany featured a Bourbon and chocolate cupcake with milk chocolate frosting infused with Bourbon, showcasing her love for this perfect combination of flavors.

Follow 5 Daughters (Brittany Ortman) on Instagram @5_daughters_columbus to explore more of her mouthwatering creations and support her small home bakery business.

Emily Hodge is a talented local home food artisan based in Columbus, IN, specializing in custom cakes and cookies. With a passion for baking, Emily often devotes her evenings to decorating her delightful creations after the kids have gone to bed. She recently showcased her skills by sharing two fantastic sets of cookies online. One set featured baseball and nurse-themed cookies, while the other showcased flower sunglasses crafted from little letter beads, cleverly combining two birthday themes: Groovy and Sunset 8th birthday. In addition to her creative designs, Emily has also expanded her offerings to include gluten-free cookies, responding to the demand from a client whose sister follows a gluten-free diet. It's been a busy few weeks for Emily as she has been hard at work making cookies to celebrate the end of soccer, tennis, and cross country seasons

Welcome to Creative Cottage Treasures
A cozy little micro bakery where homemade meets heartmade.

At Creative Cottage Treasures, we specialize in small-batch, handcrafted baked goods made with love and quality ingredients, from our signature sourdough loaves to seasonal favorites.

Creative Cottage Treasures  | Columbus, IN

The calendar below outlines my general availability and is reference only. More accurate availability is provided when submitting a request or at checkout.

Availability

Please provide your details and message below and I'll be in touch soon.

Get in Touch

Shop our back to school treats and make the start of the school year extra special!

📚 Start the School Year Right

Freshly baked and full of flavor—perfect for your holiday feast or as a thoughtful gift!

🦃 Celebrate Thanksgiving with Our Homemade Baked Goods!

Creative Cottage Treasures 

Please select an item below to view options, availability, and to begin a quote.

Order Forms

Welcome to The Alley ! I'm Jennifer, proudly serving customers in the Columbus area. Thanks for stopping by! Please don't hesitate to reach out if you have any questions and be sure to subscribe to my email list for discounts and shop updates. Thank you for supporting The Alley ! 

From the best specialty food artisans to your home in no time!

Results near Columbus, IN

$15.00

$12.00

$10.00

$5.00

$5.00

$30.00

$10.00

$3.00

$4.00

$14.00

$14.00

$12.00

$2.50

$18.00

$14.00

$5.00

$14.00

Become a Seller

For Sellers

Seller Log In

Become a Seller

Who is Castiron?

Why Sell on Castiron Marketplace?

Pricing

Resources

About Castiron

Contact Support

Return Policy

Sitemap

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Sitemap