Customizable Sugar Cookies, the perfect treat for any occasion. Our cookies are baked fresh with only the finest ingredients, ensuring a soft and chewy texture with every bite. Our Sugar Cookies are fully customizable to your preferences, allowing you to choose the shape, size, and design that best suits your needs. Whether you're looking for a fun and creative way to celebrate a special occasion or just want to enjoy a sweet treat, our Sugar Cookies are the perfect choice. We use only high-quality ingredients, including fresh butter, flour, and sugar, to create our cookies. Plus, we offer a variety of flavors and colors to choose from, including classic vanilla, chocolate, and funfetti, as well as custom colors to match your event's theme. Our Sugar Cookies are perfect for any occasion, from birthdays and weddings to corporate events and holidays. They make great party favors, dessert platters, or a sweet gift for someone special. So why settle for generic store-bought cookies when you can indulge in the delicious and customizable taste of our Sugar Cookies? Order yours today and experience the perfect balance of sweetness and softness in every bite.

My Story

Welcome to Sierra's Sweets! I'm Sierra, proudly serving customers in the Louisville area. Thanks for stopping by! Please don't hesitate to reach out if you have any questions and be sure to subscribe to my email list for discounts and shop updates. Thank you for supporting Sierra's Sweets! 

Custom Sugar Cookies

This set of cookies is sure to wow any dad on Father's Day. This set comes with 6 soft baked sugar cookies to look like a cheeseburger.

Welcome to The Whisk House! I'm Lindsay, proudly serving customers in New Albany, IN and the surrounding area. Thanks for stopping by! Please don't hesitate to reach out if you have any questions and be sure to subscribe to my email list for discounts and shop updates. Thank you for supporting The Whisk House! I started The Whisk House back in 2017. I only did cakes for family and friends. After all of their love and support, I started taking custom orders.I have always loved being in the kitchen no matter what I was baking/cooking. It's my happy place. Fast forward to 2023, I got married, had two beautiful daughters and I have now started helping brides with their dream wedding cake. It has been a huge honor to be a part of their special day. We currently are taking orders for custom sugar cookies, cakes and weddings.

Flippin' Awesome Dad

This 6 cookie set is sure to wow any new homeowner with excellent detail design to the delectable soft, chewy flavor of the cookie. It comes in a variety of flavors. Vanilla, Ghirardelli Chocolate, and Strawberry.

House Warming Cookie Set

Indulge in the delightful sweetness of The Whisk House's Custom Cream Cheese Sugar Cookies, baked in our small, insured cottage home-based kitchen in New Albany, IN. Each perfectly golden cookie is made with the highest quality ingredients like fresh milk, eggs, and flour.Please note: our cookies are made in a kitchen where these allergens are present.

Decorative Sugar Cookies

These custom-decorated Buttercream Sugar Cookies are a delectable treat. Each cookie features a sweet, melt-in-your-mouth buttercream topping that perfectly complements the rich, chewy sugar cookie beneath. These cookies bring you the delicious satisfaction of home-baked goods, displaying a unique desgin to celebrate every occasion.

Rose Buttercream Sugar cookies 

Jessica Kilpatrick is a talented self-taught baker based in Louisville, Kentucky, with a strong desire to expand her baking horizons. Known for her mouthwatering creations, Jessica recently delighted her followers with delectable English Muffins that are both easy to make and surpass store-bought options. She also shared a recipe for delicious and irresistible brownie bites, perfect for satisfying any dessert lover's cravings. Additionally, Jessica showcased her skill in crafting homemade hamburger buns that are both easy and tasty, garnering significant attention on viral reels. As the holiday season came and went, Jessica added a festive touch by introducing her must-have chocolate crinkle cookies that are sure to grace every holiday table. To top it off, she also recommended the absolute best dinner rolls ever, directing her audience to the recipe found on @joyfoodsunshine. With each new creation, Jessica's passion for baking shines through, leaving her followers eager for more delectable treats.

Bluegrass Cookie Company is a local home food artisan run by Angela Fishburn, a mom of two and a teacher. While temporarily closed at the moment, Bluegrass Cookie Company is known for its custom cookies in Louisville, Kentucky. Recently, they celebrated Mother's Day and expressed gratitude to all the amazing mothers who hold the world together. They also reminded customers about the Derby cookie pickups and thanked everyone for supporting their small business. Additionally, Bluegrass Cookie Company shared a limited flash sale for Derby cookies, which included various designs like jockey silks, horse heads, and Kentucky-shaped cookies. They have also showcased their ability to create cookies that match specific themes, as seen in their collaboration with @the.hat.doctor, where they made hat cookies for an event at the @kendrascott store in @oxmoorcenter. Overall, Bluegrass Cookie Company takes pride in their delicious and beautifully designed cookies that bring joy to special occasions.

Donald Joiner is a local home food artisan who specializes in creating Crystal Candy Silicone Mats and other related products. With a passion for quality and creativity, Donald's products are highly sought after by home bakers and cooking enthusiasts. In addition to his artisanal endeavors, Donald is an active member of the baking community, collaborating with other professionals such as Laurie Collins and Deborah Coughlin of CBC Designs, LLC. Recently, he shared posts on social media, expressing his love for Lemon Tile Cookies and showcasing his involvement in various baking classes and projects, including a tribute to the late Nicholas Lodge. With his innovative products and dedication to his craft, Donald Joiner continues to inspire and delight fellow sugar enthusiasts and foodies alike.



Michelle is a talented local home food artisan specializing in custom cookies. Although currently on hiatus, Michelle recently shared some of her amazing creations on social media. She showcased a variety of themed cookie sets, including a sweet set to celebrate her best friend's new baby, a gluten-free set to welcome and guide a new celiac friend, an adventure set to welcome a new baby, and a set of bourbon and cigar cookies to celebrate a close friend's birthday. Michelle's attention to detail and creativity shine through in her work, with hand-painted bourbon cookies, edible watercolors, textured cigar "paper," and meticulously crafted animal designs. Even though she encountered some challenges along the way, Michelle's dedication and passion for her craft are evident in the final results.

The Yellow Door Cookies is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY, specializing in delicious and homemade cookies for all special occasions. With a passion for baking, The Yellow Door Cookies provides a wide variety of cookies to suit every taste and celebration. Their cookies are perfect for birthdays, holidays, weddings, and more, and are made with love and attention to detail. From mini Christmas cookies to themed wedding cookies, The Yellow Door Cookies offers a unique and tasty treat for any event.

In their recent social media posts, The Yellow Door Cookies shows their excitement and creativity in celebrating various occasions. From commemorating the last day of school with ice cream to showcasing their festive mini Christmas cookies, The Yellow Door Cookies adds a touch of sweetness to any special moment. They also highlight their cookies as a way to celebrate a sweet boy's 8th birthday and gear up for Halloween festivities. With their dedication to providing delightful and themed cookies, The Yellow Door Cookies is the go-to artisan for delectable treats in Louisville.

Nicolette’sHouseOfSweets is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY. With a specialty in cookies and cakes, Nicolette's creations are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Unfortunately, they do not offer shipping, but customers can reach out via direct message for custom inquiries. Recently, Nicolette shared the most fun, yet messy cake decorating job to date, showcasing their talent and dedication to creating edible works of art. They also fulfilled an 11th birthday cookie order with a touch of a Glo-Silent Disco theme, as well as a favorite flamingo pull-apart birthday cake, perfect for a little kid's party. Nicolette'sHouseOfSweets is passionate about cakes and recently supported the @ascensionparishlouisville Summer Festival cake booth. Offering a variety of treats, such as Jo.Jo cookies, they recently designed a colorful tie-dye, glitter-filled 6th birthday creation that embraced love and celebration.

Grandmother's Cookie Jar is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY, offering an array of delicious and beautifully decorated sugar cookies. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a tasty treat, Grandmother's Cookie Jar has you covered. From drop cookies to cookie cakes, their delightful creations are perfect for any event in the Louisville area.

Recently, Grandmother's Cookie Jar shared some exciting posts. With back-to-school season approaching, they suggest sending your student off with a bag full of love and good wishes. Their sweet set of six mini hearts comes in an adorable bag and includes an edible marker for personalizing notes. Additionally, for those seeking a fall treat without a Halloween theme, Grandmother's Cookie Jar presents adorable truck bags with three pumpkin cookies available in vanilla sugar or pumpkin spice. It's the perfect retreat for the autumn season. If you're a fan of fall beverages, they also ask for your favorite - whether it's apple cider, hot tea, hot chocolate, or coffee. Finally, the post reminds followers to place their orders for Halloween cookies, with a range of options available, including decorate-your-own kits, paint-your-own sets, cookie cards, and a cute Halloween man. Don't miss out!

Kathy's Konfections is a local home food artisan located in Louisville, KY. Run by Kathy, a konfections konnoisseur, Kathy's Konfections offers custom cookies and macarons for various occasions including bridal showers, weddings, birthdays, baby showers, and more. With a passion for baking, Kathy creates unique and delicious treats that are perfect for celebrating special days. From baby-themed sets to breast cancer awareness cookies, Kathy's Konfections offers a wide range of options to cater to different tastes and interests. Whether you're looking for something sweet to commemorate a milestone or to support a cause, Kathy's Konfections has got you covered.

Recently, Kathy's Konfections introduced special flavors for the fall season. Indulge in the delightful Apple macarons with a caramel apple buttercream and caramel center, or try the Pecan Pie macarons for a nutty and sweet treat. And because fall wouldn't be complete without pumpkin spice, Kathy's Konfections offers a pumpkin spice cheesecake macaron as well. These seasonal flavors are only available for a limited time, so make sure to get your hands on these delectable treats while you can. Visit kathyskonfectionsllc.square.site/order-form to place your order and experience the mouthwatering goodness of Kathy's Konfections.

Fright Bites is a local home food artisan that specializes in serving up booo-gie bar food, light bites, and horror-ific desserts. Led by Chef Terror, Fright Bites offers a unique and spooky culinary experience. With a variety of treats on offer, customers can indulge in treats like the "Strawberries & Scream" - a lofthouse sugar cookie filled with strawberry preserves and topped with vanilla buttercream, or the "Van Helsing" - a black forest cupcake filled with kirsch soaked cherries and topped with vanilla buttercream and a chocolate covered pretzel "Stake." Chef Terror frequently pops up at local events, such as the opening night at Actors Theatre Louisville and the Devil's Night Masquerade Ball at Art Sanctuary, offering delectable bites and a bloody good time. For those looking to join in on the fun, make sure to follow @chef_terror for updates and information on where to find these spooky treats.

Southern Charm Cookie Co is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, Kentucky. They specialize in creating sweet and charming cookie creations that are designed with love and attention to detail. With a passion for cookie artistry, Southern Charm Cookie Co offers a wide range of beautifully decorated cookies for various occasions, including baby showers. Their recent posts showcase their expertise in creating adorable orange-themed cookies, featuring intricate designs and techniques like wet-on-wet icing. From packaging to cookie design, Southern Charm Cookie Co's commitment to excellence is evident in every aspect of their work, making them a go-to choice for those who appreciate the artistry and deliciousness of handmade cookies.

To place an order with Southern Charm Cookie Co, visit the link provided in their bio on @southerncharmdesign.

Cookielicious Confections is a local home food artisan specializing in custom cookies for every occasion. With a self-taught baker at the helm, they create delicious treats that are perfect for celebrations, gifts, or simply indulging in something sweet. Whether you're celebrating a graduation, showing appreciation for nurses, or highlighting a personal achievement, Cookielicious Confections has you covered. They offer cookie bouquets and dozens of cookies that can be customized to suit your preferences. Don't miss out on their limited-time offerings and be sure to place your order soon before their available dates fill up!

Recent posts from Cookielicious Confections showcase their dedication to creating cookies for a wide range of occasions. From commemorating National Nurses Week with thoughtful nurse-themed cookies to celebrating the academic achievements of the Class of 2022 with custom graduation cookies, they infuse creativity into their delectable treats. Cookielicious Confections also takes pride in acknowledging personal milestones like signing with Kentucky State University, using cookies as a delicious way to honor accomplishments. With a passion for meeting customers' desires, they even explore unique flavors like Bourbon Barrel and Marijuana cookies, aiming to give people exactly what they want. Don't miss out on their delectable offerings and be sure to place your order before the Sunday, May 1st deadline.

Danielle Miller is a talented self-taught baker based in Louisville, KY. She is the owner of Jamm & Jelly's Treats, a local home food artisan specializing in delicious baked goods. Danielle offers a variety of treats, including her famous soft and melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter cookies, available with or without chocolate chips. Made fresh to order, these cookies are priced at $20 per dozen. Additionally, Jamm & Jelly's Treats creates delightful vanilla cupcakes with vanilla buttercream frosting, perfect for any occasion. You can find Danielle's mouthwatering creations on her Facebook page, where she showcases her expertise in baking and promotes her home bakery to the local community in Louisville, KY.

Bobbi's Bakeshop is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY. With a background in photography and baking, Bobbi offers pre-sales of delicious homemade treats. However, Bobbi is currently not taking custom orders, as she is focusing on her photography business. You can find her stunning creations on her Instagram page, @bobbiphoto. From adorable baby shower cookies to themed Harry Potter designs, Bobbi's Bakeshop brings its artistic touch to every treat. Whether it's Valentine's Day or the Kentucky Derby, Bobbi's Bakeshop is known for its attention to detail and delectable sugar cookies. Spread the love and indulge in the sweet delights from Bobbi's Bakeshop!

Sweets by Millie is a boutique bakery based in Louisville, Kentucky that specializes in creating custom cakes and desserts. With an eye for detail, they are known for their intricate buttercream piping details and beautiful floral designs on their wedding cakes, as showcased in their recent post. Whether it's a 90's birthday party or a wedding celebration at Germantown Gables, Sweets by Millie has the expertise to create custom cookies and cakes that capture the essence of any occasion. With their attention to detail and personal touch, Sweets by Millie is the go-to bakery in Louisville for all your sweet indulgences, and they can be contacted via email at sweetsbymillie@gmail.com to place an order. 

In addition to their wedding cakes, Sweets by Millie also specializes in gender reveal cakes and baby shower cookies, as seen in their recent posts. Their adorable teddy bear cookies and charming gender reveal cake designs reflect their passion for creating memorable moments and sweet treats for special occasions. Located in Louisville, their boutique bakery is committed to providing custom cakes and desserts that bring joy to every celebration. Whether it's a wedding, birthday, or baby shower, Sweets by Millie loves to sweeten up life's milestones with their delectable creations.

Sweet Time Baking is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY. With a passion for baking that spans five generations, Sweet Time Baking is committed to bringing joy to customers' celebrations with delicious treats. While DMs may occasionally be missed, ordering can be done conveniently through email or Facebook Messenger. Stay tuned for their exciting Valentine's orders, which will include DIY kits, personalized options, mini Valentine cards, and more. Sweet Time Baking aims to accommodate customers by offering pickups on Sunday, February 13, between 12-2pm, with potential alternative arrangements upon prior communication. Keep an eye out for details on their drop-cookie options, anti-Valentine's options, and Galentine options, and don't forget to check out their flashback to a favorite creation from last year.

The Louisville Bakery is a local home food artisan that specializes in homemade cakes, cookies, and treats. With a passion for baking, they create delicious and beautifully decorated confections that are perfect for any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, a special event, or simply craving something sweet, The Louisville Bakery has you covered. Their range of offerings includes sugar cookies, cakes, and more, all made with love and attention to detail.

Recently, The Louisville Bakery posted a series of enticing and creative posts on their social media accounts. From a delightful tea-themed sugar cookie set to a charming Madison-inspired sprinkle cookie, their designs are both eye-catching and mouthwatering. They also showcased their talent with divorce-themed cookies, showing that they can bring a touch of humor to any occasion. Additionally, they shared a volleyball-themed assortment of sugar cookies that brought back nostalgia for their own athletic history. Finally, they celebrated the arrival of spring with a berry birthday cake, showcasing their ability to create both visually stunning and delicious creations. Whatever your sweet tooth desires, The Louisville Bakery is sure to deliver a delightful and delectable treat.

Helen Stringer is a talented local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY. Specializing in cookies, Helen runs her business, Helen's Cookie Creations (HCC), as a home-based processor. Offering custom and holiday orders, Helen's cookies are made with love and attention to detail. With her creative skills and passion for baking, she delights in designing and baking custom cookies for important life events. Whether it's a birthday, anniversary, or any other special moment, Helen's Cookie Creations can help you celebrate with delicious and beautifully decorated cookies. With local pick-up options and a variety of cookie designs, Helen's creations are perfect for adding a sweet touch to your celebrations.

Kristin Spalding is a talented home-based bakery artisan located in Louisville, KY. With a passion for creating delicious treats, Kristin specializes in making custom cookies with intricate designs. To place an order, you can reach out to her via email at kristinspalding@gmail.com. Recently, Kristin showcased her skills by creating beautifully decorated fall-themed cookies for a company party, as well as adorable red and pink cookies for a sweet one-year-old birthday celebration. She also impressed with her elegant teacup and wedding dress designs for a bridal tea/shower event. Additionally, Kristin expressed her pride for a graduate in Iowa City through a heartfelt cookie creation, and even combined her love for jazzercise with her baking talents to make cookies for Jazzercise Crestwood's 25th-anniversary celebration. No matter the occasion, Kristin's royal icing cookies are a delightful and visually appealing treat.

Robin's Sugar Nest is a local home food artisan based in the bluegrass state. By day, Robin is a servant leader, but her true passion lies in being a hobby cookie artist. She is known for her love of Kentucky Derby hats and has even participated in the CookieCon Show, winning second place in 2022 and third place in 2021. With a keen eye for detail and a dedication to her craft, Robin creates custom decorated cookies that are truly works of art. From wedding cookies to birthday treats, her creations are a testament to her skill and creativity. Follow along on her journey as she shares her cookie adventures and love for all things sweet at Robin's Sugar Nest.

Robin recently posted about her son's beautiful wedding, where she played a significant role in making it a special day of love. From the food to the decor, her family put in an incredible amount of work, and she hosted it at "The Nest". Despite a little chaos, Robin managed to create some rustic carrot cake and a two-tier wedding cake that received lots of compliments, surprising her as it was her first attempt. She also fondly reminisces about her niece's wedding, capturing sentimental moments like her little brother walking her down the aisle and toasts that touched her heart. Robin's passion for her craft shines through as she shares her love for sugar cookies, edible art, and the joy of creating custom decorated cookies. Join in on the sweetness of Robin's Sugar Nest as she creates beautiful and delicious treats for every occasion.

Lex's Custom Cookies is a local home food artisan based in Louisville, KY🐎. They have been creating custom treats since 2020 and are available for local orders only. To place an order, click the link in their bio. Lex's Custom Cookies specializes in decorated cookies, including mom-to-be cookies, sugar cookies, wedding cookies, and more. Their recent posts include a variety of beautifully decorated cookies, such as ring cookies for weddings, a 1st birthday set inspired by sunshine, and heart cookies for Valentine's Day. They also offer a "favorite things" set as a great option for birthday parties without a specific theme. With Lex's Custom Cookies, love is always in season and they provide delicious treats for every occasion.

From the best specialty food artisans to your home in no time!

Custom Decorated Cookies near Louisville, KY

CS

Starts at: $40.00

$25.00

Starts at: $27.50

Starts at: $100.00

Starts at: $85.00

Become a Seller

For Sellers

Seller Log In

Become a Seller

Who is Castiron?

Why Sell on Castiron Marketplace?

Pricing

Resources

About Castiron

Contact Support

Return Policy

Sitemap

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Sitemap