Indulge in the rich, nostalgic flavor of our Plowman's Peanut Butter Cookie. You will receive a bundle of three 3oz cookies . The Plowman's Peanut Butter cookie is crafted with the perfect balance of crunchy peanut butter, oatmeal, free-range eggs, and homemade pure vanilla extract this home-baked delight will transport you back to simpler times. Enjoy a taste of homemade goodness in every bite! We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays or Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday ensuring they reach you at peak freshness. Minimum order of $25

Welcome!

Welcome to I Am Cookie and Sugar Company! At I Am Cookie and Sugar Company, baking is more than a craft - it’s a tradition passed down through generations.I grew up in a family where everyone was taught how to cook and bake. My grandmother use to say, “It doesn’t matter if you’re male or female, you should know how to cook and know how to bake - just in case you have a sweet tooth.”From a young age, I found myself in the kitchen with my grandmother, mother, and sometimes my grandfather, learning the art of creating comforting meals and sweet treats.While I learned to cook, my heart always belonged to baking. Today, I’m proud to carry on those lessons, creating scratch-made, Southern luxury desserts - cookies and brownies crafted with the finest ingredients and a whole lot of love, just like my grandmother and mother taught me.Whether you’re celebrating a special event, catering a corporate gathering, or simply craving something delicious, we’re here to make your moments a little sweeter. Welcome to our kitchen - from my heart to yours.Kimberly

Plowman's Peanut Butter Cookie

Indulge in pure decadence with our Celebration Brownie Box. Each box features a delightful assortment of rich, fudgy brownies perfect for any occasion. Treat yourself or surprise someone special with this scrumptious ensemble of homemade goodness! Each box will have four each of Butter Bliss, Chocolate Madness, and The Best of Both Worlds.Butter Bliss -Brownie base with cookie butter buttercream, cookie butter drizzle and topped with Biscoff cookie.Chocolate Madness - Brownie base with chocolate buttercream, and topped with Oreo cookies.Best of Both Worlds - Brownie base with vanilla buttercream and topped with our famous Cookie &amp; Dream cookie. Please place your order a minimum of 3-4 days before day of delivery.

Celebration Brownie Box 

Indulge in the festive delight of 'Birthday Party', a luscious homemade treat made with love, homemade vanilla extract, and free-range eggs from I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company based in beautiful Sanford, NC. Our cookies come to you in a bundle of 3 biggie size cookies. Every bite of this sumptuous dessert bursts with the comforting taste of rich chocolate chips and playful sprinkles, providing the perfect sweet surprise for any celebration. Order now to experience an immediate journey of flavor, sure to make your everyday taste like a birthday party! We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays or Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday ensuring they reach you at peak freshness. We offer local delivery and local pick- up. Minimum order of $25

Birthday Party  

Indulge in the ultimate treat with our 11-Inch Custom Cookie Cake, crafted to perfection by I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC. Bursting with rich, gooey chocolate chips in every bite, this generously sized cookie cake offers a delightful twist on a classic favorite. Perfect for celebrations or simple sweet cravings, it's a delicious way to share the love.Also, available in Chocolate Overload, Birthday Party, Gourmet Snickerdoodle, Cookies and Dream, or Red Velvet. Serves 10-12Please place order 4-7 days prior to event.Delivery or Pick Up Only.

Chocolate Chip Cake 

Experience indulgence at its finest with Luxury Brownies from I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company of Sanford, NC. These gourmet delights, homemade from top-tier ingredients, balance a decadent, fudge center with a splendidly crusty exterior. Lose yourself in a rich, chocolatey journey made possible by genuine small-batch craftsmanship.-1 Butter Bliss - Cookie butter buttercream frosting drizzled with cookie butter and topped with Biscoff cookie-1 Chocolate Madness - Chocolate buttercream frosting topped with Oreo cookies-1 Best of the Best World - Our signature buttercream frosting topped with out famous Cookies &amp; Dream cookie-1 Caramel Delight - Caramel buttercream frosting with caramel drizzle topped with dark chocolate chips Minimum order of $25Delivery or Pick Up Only

Luxury Brownie Box 

Indulge in the nostalgic flavors of our Campfire S'More Cookie, a delightful creation by I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC. Each quarter pound cookie is a harmonious blend of gooey marshmallows, rich chocolate chips, and crunchy graham crackers, capturing the essence of a classic fireside treat. Perfectly baked and irresistibly delicious, it's a sweet escape to campfire memories with every bite. Order includes a bundle of 3 biggie size cookies. We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays or Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday ensuring they reach you at peak freshness.We offer local delivery and local pick-up. Minimum order $25

Campfire S’More Cookie

Indulge in sweet perfection with our Custom 10-inch Heart Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake, lovingly crafted by I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC. This delectable treat combines the classic charm of a chocolate chip cookie with personalized touches, making it an ideal centerpiece for any celebration. Whether for birthdays, anniversaries, or just because, this heart-shaped delight is sure to warm hearts and satisfy taste buds.Also, available in Chocolate Overload, Birthday Party, Gourmet Snickerdoodle, Cookies and Dream, or Red Velvet. Serves 10-12Delivery or Pick Up Onlyplease place order 4-7 days prior to event.

Custom 10-inch Heart  Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake 

Indulge in pure joy with our 11-inch Gourmet Snickerdoodle Cookie Cake, an irresistible blend of cinnamon and sugar crafted to perfection. Each cake is accompanied by a personalized sugar cookie, adding a sweet touch for any occasion. Baked fresh by I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC, this delightful duo promises to elevate your dessert experience. Also, available in Chocolate Overload, Birthday Party, Classic Chocolate Chip, Cookies and Dream, or Red Velvet. Please place order 4-7 prior to event.Serves10-12Delivery or Pick-up Only

Gourmet Snickerdoodle Cookie Cake

Indulge in the ultimate sweet treat with our Chocolate Chip Crookie from I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC. Our crookies come to you in a bundle of 3. This delicious hybrid combines the best of a cookie and a croissant, offering layers of buttery, flaky goodness studded with rich chocolate chips. Perfect for a gourmet snack or a decadent dessert, it's a must-try for any chocolate lover! We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays or Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday ensuring they reach you at peak freshness. Minimum order of $25

Chocolate Chip Crookie

Indulge in the irresistible flavor of I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company's Summer Strawberry Sugar Cookies, lovingly baked in the heart of Sanford, NC. Our cookies come to you in a bundle of 3 biggie size cookies. Each bite blends the sweetness of strawberries, white chocolate chips with a delightful sugary crunch, making for a perfect summertime treat. Homemade with high-quality ingredients and a lot of love, these cookies are a testament to the classic comfort of homemade goodness. We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday, ensuring they reach you at peak freshness.We offer local delivery and/or local pick up. Minimum order of $25

Summer Strawberry Sugar Cookie 

Indulge in the delightful decadence of our Little Tipsy Irish Cream Cookie, handcrafted by I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC. Each bite masterfully blends rich Irish cream flavor, with a soft, buttery cookie base and milk chocolate chips, making it the perfect grown-up treat for any occasion. Elevate your snack time with this exquisite taste experience, baked with love and premium ingredients. Bundle of 3Minimum order of $25 We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday, ensuring they reach you at peak freshness.We offer local pick up and/or local delivery.

Little Tipsy 

Brace yourselves for the Beyond Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookie from I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company, Sanford, NC. Our cookies come to you in a bundle of 3 biggie size cookies. This decadent cookie combines the rich, creamy flavors of peanut butter cup with the indulgent sweetness of chocolate, creating an irresistible treat for any dessert lover. Made from scratch with love, our homemade vanilla extract, free-range eggs, and baked to yummy perfection, this cookie is set to elevate your snacking experience beyond the ordinary. We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays or Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday ensuring they reach you at peak freshness. We offer local delivery and/or local pick-up. Minimum order of $25

Beyond Chocolate

Indulge in the decadent delight of our Chocolate Roses Heart Shaped Brownie Cake, baked with love by I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company in Sanford, NC. This rich, fudgy brownie cake is beautifully adorned with delicate chocolate buttercream rose accents, making it the perfect treat for any special occasion or heartfelt gift. Savor each bite of this exquisite dessert and experience the warmth of a homemade touch. Serves 10-12Delivery or Pick-up OnlyPlease place order 4-7 days prior to delivery or pick-up day.

Chocolate Roses  Brownie  Cake 

A timeless favorite that feels like home. Our classic chocolate chip cookie is made with our finest semi-sweet chocolate chips and rich, golden dough — soft in the center, crisp on the edges, and perfect for savoring on a sunny front porch. Bundle of 3 biggie size cookiesMinimum order of $25 We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday, ensuring they reach you at peak freshness. We offer shipping, local delivery and/or local pick up.

Front Porch Classic (Chocolate Chip) 

Inspired by the classic Southern dessert, this cookie is soft, buttery, and packed with real banana flavor, creamy white chocolate chips, and bits of vanilla wafer for that nostalgic banana pudding crunch in every bite. Bundle of 3 biggie sizeMinimum order of $25 We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday, ensuring they reach you at peak freshness.We offer local pick up and/or local delivery.

Southern Banana Pudding Cookie

Just like something you'd sneak from Grandma’s cookie jar. This hearty oatmeal raisin cookie is soft, chewy, and spiced just right, with plump raisins and a touch of nostalgia in every bite — straight from Grannie's pantry to yours. Bundle of 3 biggie size cookiesMinimum order $25 We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday, ensuring they reach you at peak freshness.We offer shipping, local delivery and/or local pick up. Minimum order of $25

Grannie's Pantry (Oatmeal Raisin) 

This brownie’s got Southern sass and sweet soul. We take our rich, fudgy brownie, slather it with smooth cookie butter frosting, then crown it with a golden cookie butter cookie — the kind that makes you close your eyes and say “mmhmm.” It’s sweet comfort, baked up and ready to bless your day. Local pick up or delivery only. Minimum Order $25

Butter on Top Brownie Slab

Two classics, one unforgettable bite. This fudgy brownie slab is topped with smooth vanilla frosting and finished with our signature Front Porch Classic chocolate chip cookie. It’s soft, sweet, and stacked with the kind of comfort that never goes out of style. Local delivery or pick up only Minimum order $25

The Classic Stack Brownie Slab 

Thick, fudgy, and full of down-home decadence. This brownie slab is slathered with creamy peanut butter frosting and topped with a chocolatey peanut butter cup for good measure. It’s a rich, muddy bite of Carolina comfort that'll stick with you — in all the best ways. Local delivery or pick up only Minimum order $25

Carolina Mud Butter Brownie Slab 

A cookie for the true cookie butter lover. This indulgent treat is made with a cookie butter dough, stuffed with creamy cookie butter, and topped with a cookie — it’s buttery, bold, and absolutely unforgettable. Bundle of 3 biggie size cookies. Minimum $25 order We want your cookies to arrive as fresh as possible! That’s why we only ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid any delays over the weekend. Any cookie orders placed before Friday will be shipped the following Monday or Tuesday, ensuring they reach you at peak freshness.We offer shipping, local delivery and/or local pick up.

Butter My Cookie (Cookie Butter)

Sister Creations is a local home bakery based in Siler City, North Carolina, serving the Asheboro, North Carolina area. They offer a delicious assortment of homemade treats that are available by order only. Customers can enjoy mouth-watering options like heart-shaped flan and customizable strawberries. With their convenient pickup service, you can satisfy your sweet tooth and support this small business at the same time. Whether it's for a special occasion or just a treat for yourself, Sister Creations has something indulgent and decadent for everyone.

Are you craving something sweet? Sister Creations has got you covered! Their recent posts showcase their creative and delectable offerings, including heart-shaped flan and customizable strawberries in various colors. They believe that Valentine's Day should be celebrated more than once a year, and they encourage you not to wait 365 days to express your love and appreciation to someone special. With their beautiful and tasty treats, you can make any day feel like Valentine's Day. Don't miss out on their cute concha bombs – place your order today and treat yourself to a delightful homemade experience!

Angelica's Arrangements is a local home food artisan based in Siler City, NC. Specializing in custom chocolate-covered strawberries, they offer a delectable array of desserts that are baked to perfection. Whether you're a cheesecake lover or in need of a sweet treat for a special occasion like a safari-themed baby shower, Angelica's Arrangements has you covered. Their menu also features unique delights like Churro Cheesecake, marble-designed cake pops, and breakable heart-shaped cakes with strawberries. With a passion for creating delicious treats and a dedication to supporting the local community, Angelica's Arrangements is your go-to destination for satisfying your sweet tooth.

To place an order, simply send them a direct message. And for Spanish speakers, don't worry, Se Habla Español! Angelica's Arrangements is grateful for the unwavering support of their customers and encourages everyone to continue supporting small businesses like theirs. So why wait? Indulge in their cake pops, strawberries, and other sweet offerings by placing your order now.

Welcome to I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company! I'm Kimberly, proudly serving customers in the Sanford, Siler City, Pittsboro, Chapel Hill, Apex, Cary, Durham, Southern Pines, Holly Springs, and Aberdeen areas. Thanks for stopping by! Please don't hesitate to reach out if you have any questions and be sure to subscribe to my email list for discounts and shop updates. Thank you for supporting I Am Cookie &amp; Sugar Company!

I Am Cookie & Sugar Company | Sanford, NC

We will respond as quickly as possible. Phone: 919-777-4326

Contact Us 

Thank you for shopping with I Am Cookie and Sugar Company, LLC. Please read the terms below before placing your order; ~All sales are final. Due to the nature of the baked goods, we do not offer refunds or exchanges. ~Orders are baked fresh and carefully packaged to ensure safe delivery. ~If your item(s) arrives damaged, it must be reported to I Am Cookie and Sugar Company, LLC within 12 hours of the confirmed delivery with a clear photo of evidence email iamcookiecompany@gmail.com. ~We are not responsible for delays, theft, or delivery issues once the package is in the hands of the courier i.e. UPS, USPS, etc. ~All packages are insured through our shipping provider, in the event of loss or damaged we will help file a claim. ~By completing your purchase, you agree to these terms.

Terms and Conditions

Policy

Celebrate Dad with a special treat just for him!

🧢 Father’s Day is June 16th!

Treat the grad in your life to something special.

🎓 It’s Graduation Season!

Shop our 4th of July treats and bring something extra special to the party this year!

🇺🇸 Elevate Your 4th of July Celebration!

Shop our back to school treats and make the start of the school year extra special!

📚 Start the School Year Right

Freshly baked and full of flavor—perfect for your holiday feast or as a thoughtful gift!

🦃 Celebrate Thanksgiving with Our Homemade Baked Goods!

Festive flavors for sharing, gifting, or indulging this season!

🎄 Sweeten Your Holidays with Our Christmas Baked Goods!

Deliciously crafted for the season—perfect for parties, trick-or-treaters, or indulging yourself!

🎃 Make Halloween Extra Spooky with Our Treats!

Savor the warm, rich flavors of fall—ideal for sharing or treating yourself!

From the best specialty food artisans to your home in no time!

Results near Siler City, NC

$15.00

$65.00

$15.00

$45.00

$22.00

$15.00

$40.00

$50.00

$18.00

$15.00

$15.00

$15.00

$40.00

$15.00

$16.00

$15.00

$12.00

$12.00

$12.00

$15.00

Become a Seller

For Sellers

Seller Log In

Become a Seller

Who is Castiron?

Why Sell on Castiron Marketplace?

Pricing

Resources

About Castiron

Contact Support

Return Policy

Sitemap

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Sitemap